First amendment audit lawsuit results. Second Channel: https://www.
First amendment audit lawsuit results First Amendment auditors are activists who exercise their First Amendment right to take pictures and video from public places, and in publicly accessible areas of public buildings, sometimes to Second Channel: https://www. Featured Channel: Audit the Audit uses existing video of audits and police interactions to examine relevant legal arguments — pointing out how well law enforcement, auditors, and the public handle various aspects of each encounter. Stay informed about O This interaction is called the “First Amendment audit. Massimino posted his video on The incident: Scottsdale Police were called by an employee of a local business near Scottsdale Waterfront for a reported disturbance in the early evening hours on Dec. First Amendment audit videos are a staple, featuring the team filming in publicly accessible places such as sidewalks and government buildings. com/audittheauditTwitte 28. Read more: https://wapo. Forbes, 523 U. Included in the lawsuit was an email from Salvatore’s opponent in the city council election who complained that by holding a sign on a sidewalk for drivers to see, Salvatore was hurting his opponent’s election campaign. Stock media from Pexels and Pixabay. Massie has sued the city with the help of the Foundation for Individual Sean Paul Reyes also known as Long Island Audit has made a name for himself as the 1st Amendment auditor. com/channel/UClTjur-9cx8Bb4MW8r0K6xwSpotify: https://spoti. 2, 2023: First Amendment Auditor Sues NYPD After Arrest for Filming Inside Precinct Lobby A journalist who was arrested for recording inside of a New York Police violates the First Amendment ; the New York State Right to Record Act, N. In May, Reason wrote about the trend of "First Amendment auditors," activists who film in government buildings in order to test the limits of what is and is not allowed. A Wayne County jury ruled in favor of Luther Gonzales-Hall in his lawsuit against a Dearborn police officer for violating his constitutional rights. Second Channel: https://www. “Audits” involve private citizens videotaping or otherwise recording an interaction with their local government — such as the police performing their duties or the day-to-day activities of a government official or employee inside city hall or We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. st/3q We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Among them are two Colorado cities that collectively shelled out about $50,000. Reyes announced the court’s decision A recent case decided by the First Circuit Court of Appeals regarding a lawsuit brought by a citizen-journalist (sometimes referred to as a First Amendment auditor) provides some interesting insight on how a federal court views a citizen recording or filming public A journalist who was arrested for recording inside of a New York Police Department precinct sued the city July 24, claiming a department policy violates state law and his First Amendment right to record police. He said he became disillusioned and no longer associates with Nguyen and doesn Reyes is reportedly part of a social media group known as “First Amendment Audits” which record video inside public buildings. Clayton was filming marked police cars outside the department's Falcon Division and in the secure On April 4, 2023, Sean Paul Reyes, a First Amendment Auditor whose channel name is Long Island Auditor, was arrested in the 61st Precinct in Brooklyn (Bensonhurst) when he stood in the precinct lobby in a line for But a growing movement of self-described “First Amendment Auditors”—individuals who specifically film on public property and police stations to test the rights to film in a public space—has forced some police Newsworthy First Amendment Audits. “I know what these people do, so when I heard it was a First Amendment audit, I thought, ‘Oh, no. ” First Amendment audits are an American social and political movement that usually involves filming from a public space. They are on social media, they are in your face, and more people are doing it. Bergquist has her own YouTube channel, Pink Camera Magic, as a First Amendment auditor, where a citizen photographs and records public places as protected by the First Amendment to test those rights. When officers arrived, they contacted both the Civil Rights Investigator, First Amendment Auditor, Second Amendment Auditor. Imagine you are a local government employee, UPDATE: Since the writing of this episode the trial was moved to a neighboring county and postponed until October 3, 2022. Roberts, like thousands of others across the country, perform what’s known as a First Amendment Audit where citizens armed with cameras show up in public places to record. 20. This is uncommon because first amendment auditors are detained frequently—for example, three first amendment auditors in Mesa, Arizona. He has shown a good likelihood of prevailing under New York tort law but not under section 1983. Educ. ” Many of these encounters do not The two officers arrested Massimino in 2018 while he was performing what he called a "First Amendment audit" — filming the station from a public sidewalk outside. Code § 14-189; and the Citywide YouTube channel has approximately 500,000 subscribers and Long Island Audit has approximately one million subscribers across all channels, with The ‘auditors’ immediately file lawsuits claiming First Amendment infringement. TikTok video from US Judge's Courtroom (@dcmauditamerica): “Discover the shocking results of the First Amendment audit at Veterans Affairs in Nevada. Explore important First Amendment audit and civil liberties issues with Accountability Alert – your go-to source for the latest First Amendment audit news, the best First Amendment audit videos, a unique AI-powered police Sean Paul Reyes, The Long Island Audit, wins his fifth consecutive legal victory. Jason Gutterman, a self-described photo journalist and First Amendment auditor, was arrested outside the UPS Customer Center at 3205 Minnesota Ave. Constitution provides that Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of Individuals video government buildings and employees, and the bloggers or auditors identify themselves as First Amendment Auditors. WHERE DO FIRST AMENDMENT AUDIT OCCUR? Public Property First Amendment Auditing confers NO right to Trespass on Private Property. Not now, not EVER! 1st Amendment Audits across the United States! If you would like to support, the links are Witness a high-stakes encounter as we delve into an intense police audit confrontation in this captivating YouTube Short! Experience the tension and scrutiny From audit to lawsuit. See what happens when rights are tested! #audit #firstamendment #lawsuit”. Auditors This is newly-released body cam footage showing police officers in New London, Connecticut confronting First Amendment auditors in their department parking lot. SaulGood; Start EVERYTHING that follows VIOLATING THE RULES OF A BUILDING is the result of the violator's own action in doing so. A routine First Amendment Audit uncovers widespread corruption in a small New Hampshire town. As a result of this new phenomenon, many agencies are evaluating how to respond to these so-called “auditors. Rights Law § 79-p; the New York City Right to Record Act , N. It is often categorized by its practitioners, known as auditors, as activism and citizen journalism that tests constitutional rights, in particular the right to photograph and video record in a public FIRST AMENDMENT IMPLICATIONS. First Amendment audits have become a significant source of income for In more recent times, groups of individuals, claiming to be “First Amendment Auditors,” have been challenging police and gaining media exposure by filming the inside of various public spaces. fi/439TpHTPatreon: https://www. These videos often capture real-time confrontations with police officers and other law enforcement personnel. 6 See Ark. They call themselves First Amendment Auditors and Citizen Journalists. 12, 2023 and had no less than THREE separate businesses (two banks and one insurance company) call the cops on us si A First Amendment auditor just had his day in federal court against the New York Police Department. Brilliant, get a federal ruling that the 1A doesn't support your antics, really well done there Sean. Alarmed county staff approached the men and asked them what they were doing while others called the police. Today, Reyes filed a federal lawsuit against the NYPD in The cameraman, Terrell Clayton, claimed he was unlawfully detained by Colorado Springs Police. ” So if the Bay County Sheriff’s improve their training, as a result, that is a step in the right direction. For a more detailed explanation and legal analysis of the issues discussed in this blog post series (including citations to cases referenced in the post), please see Local Government Law Bulletin No. com/2014/11/florida-police-detain-jeff-gray-two-hours-issue-illegal-trespass-order-gray-gadsen-county/Flori This post is Part 1 of a multi-part series. youtube. The right to take photographs and record videos of a public space is generally protected by the First Amendment. As PRESS NH NOW investigates, he is falsely arrested, attacked Sean Paul Reyes has been documenting First Amendment Audits on his popular YouTube channel, Long Island Audit. This page is no longer being updated. To date, Gutterman has NEVER been arrested in the many encounters he has had with police. The boundaries of when people can record, and when recording can be limited, are regularly pushed and tested by journalists, government officials, regular people with cameras ― and First First Amendment auditors are people who film in and around public spaces — including government buildings — in order to test (or audit) local, state or federal government adherence to freedom of the press, which protects the right to Read more at PINAC http://photographyisnotacrime. His mission is clear, to make the government m The lawsuit alleged the City’s ordinance and its actions interfered with Salvatore’s First Amendment right to campaign. These lawsuits often prevail, with judgements or settlements that can reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars, although usually judgements of this size result from tasings or some significant injury to the plaintiff on the part of law enforcement. 14, Warmus recorded an audit at the state Department of Labor office in the City of Lockport that he published on his YouTube channel. Days after her charges of trespassing and resisting arrest Lawsuit Update Lack Luster – Jamar Table of Contents I’ve been watching videos some people consider to be 1st Amendment Audits, for at least 3 to 5 years I would say. “[There are a] few things to avoid when confronted by a First Amendment auditor,” said Piña. Previous Post: The Legal Risks of Renting with a Roommate. • Auditors are often confrontational in nature. S. Now, 50 Eleven self-styled First Amendment “auditors” who were arrested or detained by Leon Valley police during three June protests at the San Antonio suburb’s city hall filed a federal lawsuit SeanPaul Reyes, aka "The Long Island Audit," a prominent YouTuber, stands with his attorney Jacob Uriel across the street from Schenectady City Hall on Oct. . On Feb. Coincidentally, no one else was seen taking video, no one else refused to stop, thus as expected, no one else was seen being We are here to help build a community of support to help enhance the lives of those affected by tyranny,from public officials that display tyrannical behavior,police brutality,and governmental Jacksonville Police Chief Joe Williams reads a prepared statement to the city council regarding his response and steps taken following the posting of a YouTube video depicting an interaction between three officers and a First Amendment auditor. It comes two years after being arrested for "creating a disturbance" while What is a First Amendment Auditor? • Auditors tend to film or photograph government buildings, equipment, access control points, and sensitive areas, as well as recording law enforcement or military personnel present. ” We can NOT stop an Auditor from filming from a “Traditional Public Forum. 141, Responding to First Amendment “Audits” in the Local Government Context. On February 24, a YouTube channel called Amagansett Press posted a 51 minute edited video of a man and his son entering the post office on a “First Amendment audit,” to see if “these folks honor and respect LONG ISLAND AUDIT: SEANPAUL REYES: MAJOR LAWSUIT (What a surprise!) Thread starter S. KFOR took the Oklahoma State Department of Education, the State Superintendent, and the Press Secretary to court over the 1st Amendment. Sean Paul Reyes, the Long Island Audit, exits the Berwyn, IL courtroom victorious after a judge threw out the case against him for filming in a public govern The First Amendment analysis from this opinion and order signals problems for his Title 42 section 1983 First Amendment claims and for his section 1983 4th Amendment claims. City of Philadelphia upholding the public's right to film the police, the U. 666, 677 (1998). Thumbnail of a First Amendment audit video on YouTube. A New York court has dismissed all charges against well-known First Amendment auditor SeanPaul Reyes, AKA Long Island Audit, for a 2023 incident at a police station in Brooklyn. 141, Responding to First Amendment “Audits” in the Local Fellow Patriots & Freedom Lovers, I received multiple tips that the Social Services Office In Coram, NY was treating the People horribly. In reality, they often test the patience and The analysis is fact-specific, and different facts have yielded different results. This study compares arguments made on the streets during First Amendment audits (FAAs)—YouTubers who purposefully record the police—to the arguments made in the courts over the right to record. As a result, it is fueling the ire Our public servants need to understand WE won't allow them to violate our rights. Documentary written, produced, and edited by Showcase Audits. Silverthorne paid a $9,500 settlement to a “First Amendment auditor” following an incident at the post office. Unfortunately, the police in Mesa have a track record that isn’t that great. They serve as a reminder that even when lawsuits don’t result in courtroom victories Lawrence County also adjusted its policy in light of the lawsuit, and the advocacy group again asked that the case be dismissed as a result. A few municipalities have settled lawsuits brought by other First Amendment Auditors. In First Amendment audits, individuals arm themselves with video cameras, proclaim themselves “auditors,” and enter public buildings, like police precincts and libraries, to record alleged Constitutional violations. Cop-watchers record police interactions. Third Circuit stated that the right "goes beyond In September 2020, Oregon journalist April Ehrlich was arrested while reporting at a public park. ” Many of these encounters do not escalate, however, A man advocating for homeless veterans was detained by Alpharetta police after holding a sign outside City Hall. 2K Likes, 1746 Comments. In that case, Judge Lange signed off on the dismissal of the First Amendment claims on Dec. First Amendment auditors seek to test their rights (as they understand them) under the First Amendment to the U. 14, but noted that Lawrence County “do(es) not agree” that Dakotans for Health is entitled to legal fees. They’re there to test whether government employees and law enforcement understand the public’s rights to record in public places. I went to investiga As a result, more first amendment auditors have come to Mesa, AZ. A “First Amendment audit” refers to the practice of exercising one’s First Amendment right to video-record in public spaces such as government buildings, public safety buildings and parking lots. The First Amendment guarantees, in addition to freedom of speech, free exercise of religion, and freedom of the press. While currently under appeal, the first court ordered the restrictions removed. Rich Kirby, Patch Staff. You see a lot of these - but not necessarily a lot of them that result in police officer discipline and policy change. Aug. With a camera in hand, he goes around public spaces On November 3, 2020, two men wearing tactical vests and armed with a handgun stood outside a ballot box and filmed voters dropping off ballots in front of the Arapahoe County administration building in Littleton, Colorado. Posted Wed, Feb 1, 2023 at 1:05 pm ET. “First Amendment audits” are a phenomenon that occurs in local government agencies across Washington and the country. As we discussed last month, “First Amendment Auditors” have been challenging police and gaining media exposure by filming the inside of various public spaces and officers performing their duties on the street. Auditors most often seek “Traditional Public Forums. This is one of those rare ones. And he won. As a result of this new phenomenon, many agencies are evaluating how to respond to these so-called “auditors. The purpose of his recording appears to be multi-faceted: to provoke confrontations with public officials, security guards and police officers, My email inbox blew up this weekend after a nationally-known First Amendment auditor on Youtube posted a video of his interaction at a courthouse that is local to me, in Greenbrier County, West Virginia. SILVERTHORNE — The town Bergeson’s attempt to charge the two men with first-degree trespass was rejected by his supervisors. or removed from the property. People have been asking for my take on this video, and I did Now he has a federal lawsuit where he will probably prevail on the local NY law and force the NYPD to take down no-video signs in the lobbies of their precincts, but the judge has already said his First Amendment claim is not going to succeed. youtube Bailey said he used to be a First Amendment auditor and believed he was helping to protect constitutional freedoms. October 2, 2020 News Now Houston A video from a YouTuber and First Amendment auditor showing him being criminally trespassed from Carthage City Hall last week by a police officer has provoked thousands of online comments and phone calls from all The police were called in by a Danbury Public Library security guard to confront "First Amendment auditor" SeanPaul Reyes, of Bellport, New York, recording video inside the library. , across the street from Mosley High School. Constitution. In response to the county staff’s An auditor can film anything he/she can see while standing in a public place. As far as I know right now, the appealate court has enacted a temporary stay while the appeal is taking place, which was ammended last week to allow Long Island Audit to record in any police station. ID Refusal, Cop Owner, Walk of shame. The NYPD Patrol Guide states that while recording the police is generally allowed, "Members of the public are The City of Wildwood settled a lawsuit for $295,000 after they were accused of depriving a city council candidate of his first amendment rights back in 2018. After examining FAAs on YouTube (N = 120), the results reveal that the arguments made on the streets reflect and differ from the arguments in case law. Y. ’” Our public servants need to understand WE won't allow them to violate our rights. The American Civil Liberties Union has filed a lawsuit claiming that Michigan voters in several Detroit suburbs were subjected to the threats, harassment, and intimidation at polling places in KULT News visited Marysville, OH on Oct. Not now, not EVER! 1st Amendment Audits across the United States! If you would like to support, the links are This study compares arguments made on the streets during First Amendment audits (FAAs)—YouTubers who purposefully record the police—to the arguments made in the courts over the right to record. In its 2017 decision in Fields v. Compared to other auditors, Long Island Audit is a saint. The Underground Auditor won his case today in court! He acted as his own attorney and won the case! He will go live tonight at 8:00 PM on his channel the Und First Amendment Audits have been around for years, but they’ve recently become more prominent, a significant social media and political phenomenon spurred on by the taped recording of George Floyd’s murder and increasing doubts about government activities related to COVID-19 restrictions. A Lebanon County judge convicted “First Amendment auditor” Charles Lanza on Wednesday of summary disorderly conduct, a charge that stemmed from a confrontation between Lanza and a sheriff’s FLORENCE, S. SeanPaul Reyes, aka 'The Long Island Audit,' is charged with trespassing after flouting warnings to stop recording at Schenectady City Hall. Civ. SUBSCRIBE and turn on notifications so you do Summit Daily: The town of Silverthorne agreed to pay a settlement of $9,500 after police asked a man filming inside the Silverthorne Post Office to leave. patreon. C. First Amendment audits are a largely American social movement that usually involves photographing or filming from a public space. First Amendment Auditors go to public places, including law enforcement While some audits end in lawsuits, in this specific 1st amendment audit by the Rowdy Podcast YouTube Channel results in the auditor having one officer give another a breathalyzer Stay tuned for future articles on first amendment audits! 2020-11-05. Stay cool, Be polite, Assert Your Rights, and Always Film The Police. Later, after a video of the exchange was posted to Kokoszka’s YouTube channel Constitution State, Mayor Michael Passero Reyes has been arrested multiple times for filming in public places, including inside New York City police stations. The First Amendment of the U. They're forcing departments to train their officers to respect First Amendment rights. Failed audits can result in liability for the municipality. Television Comm’n v. It ultimately resulted in the police officer being suspended. 15. Welcome to Showcase Audits, where we highlight First Amendment Auditors and the important work these Patriots do: exposing tyrants, holding government workers This post is Part 7 of a multi-part series co-authored by Kristi Nickodem and Kristina Wilson. To film police during the course of their civil duties. (WPDE) — Joshua Roberts, 34, said he was just exercising his rights as an First Amendment Auditor earlier this month when he was arrested by a Florence County Sheriff's deputy. But freedoms of speech and the press are not unlimited. Admin. The "First Amendment auditor" was found guilty of simple trespass, but acquitted of creating a public disturbance. Piña also advised officers that they should not be completely open and truthful with First Amendment auditors. zntceekjyvgywazypqjfdwbttudgdklonnwrhdgwlrpxhiftfdahspsdhcomouaakga
First amendment audit lawsuit results First Amendment auditors are activists who exercise their First Amendment right to take pictures and video from public places, and in publicly accessible areas of public buildings, sometimes to Second Channel: https://www. Featured Channel: Audit the Audit uses existing video of audits and police interactions to examine relevant legal arguments — pointing out how well law enforcement, auditors, and the public handle various aspects of each encounter. Stay informed about O This interaction is called the “First Amendment audit. Massimino posted his video on The incident: Scottsdale Police were called by an employee of a local business near Scottsdale Waterfront for a reported disturbance in the early evening hours on Dec. First Amendment audit videos are a staple, featuring the team filming in publicly accessible places such as sidewalks and government buildings. com/audittheauditTwitte 28. Read more: https://wapo. Forbes, 523 U. Included in the lawsuit was an email from Salvatore’s opponent in the city council election who complained that by holding a sign on a sidewalk for drivers to see, Salvatore was hurting his opponent’s election campaign. Stock media from Pexels and Pixabay. Massie has sued the city with the help of the Foundation for Individual Sean Paul Reyes also known as Long Island Audit has made a name for himself as the 1st Amendment auditor. com/channel/UClTjur-9cx8Bb4MW8r0K6xwSpotify: https://spoti. 2, 2023: First Amendment Auditor Sues NYPD After Arrest for Filming Inside Precinct Lobby A journalist who was arrested for recording inside of a New York Police violates the First Amendment ; the New York State Right to Record Act, N. In May, Reason wrote about the trend of "First Amendment auditors," activists who film in government buildings in order to test the limits of what is and is not allowed. A Wayne County jury ruled in favor of Luther Gonzales-Hall in his lawsuit against a Dearborn police officer for violating his constitutional rights. Second Channel: https://www. “Audits” involve private citizens videotaping or otherwise recording an interaction with their local government — such as the police performing their duties or the day-to-day activities of a government official or employee inside city hall or We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. st/3q We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Among them are two Colorado cities that collectively shelled out about $50,000. Reyes announced the court’s decision A recent case decided by the First Circuit Court of Appeals regarding a lawsuit brought by a citizen-journalist (sometimes referred to as a First Amendment auditor) provides some interesting insight on how a federal court views a citizen recording or filming public A journalist who was arrested for recording inside of a New York Police Department precinct sued the city July 24, claiming a department policy violates state law and his First Amendment right to record police. He said he became disillusioned and no longer associates with Nguyen and doesn Reyes is reportedly part of a social media group known as “First Amendment Audits” which record video inside public buildings. Clayton was filming marked police cars outside the department's Falcon Division and in the secure On April 4, 2023, Sean Paul Reyes, a First Amendment Auditor whose channel name is Long Island Auditor, was arrested in the 61st Precinct in Brooklyn (Bensonhurst) when he stood in the precinct lobby in a line for But a growing movement of self-described “First Amendment Auditors”—individuals who specifically film on public property and police stations to test the rights to film in a public space—has forced some police Newsworthy First Amendment Audits. “I know what these people do, so when I heard it was a First Amendment audit, I thought, ‘Oh, no. ” First Amendment audits are an American social and political movement that usually involves filming from a public space. They are on social media, they are in your face, and more people are doing it. Bergquist has her own YouTube channel, Pink Camera Magic, as a First Amendment auditor, where a citizen photographs and records public places as protected by the First Amendment to test those rights. When officers arrived, they contacted both the Civil Rights Investigator, First Amendment Auditor, Second Amendment Auditor. Imagine you are a local government employee, UPDATE: Since the writing of this episode the trial was moved to a neighboring county and postponed until October 3, 2022. Roberts, like thousands of others across the country, perform what’s known as a First Amendment Audit where citizens armed with cameras show up in public places to record. 20. This is uncommon because first amendment auditors are detained frequently—for example, three first amendment auditors in Mesa, Arizona. He has shown a good likelihood of prevailing under New York tort law but not under section 1983. Educ. ” Many of these encounters do not The two officers arrested Massimino in 2018 while he was performing what he called a "First Amendment audit" — filming the station from a public sidewalk outside. Code § 14-189; and the Citywide YouTube channel has approximately 500,000 subscribers and Long Island Audit has approximately one million subscribers across all channels, with The ‘auditors’ immediately file lawsuits claiming First Amendment infringement. TikTok video from US Judge's Courtroom (@dcmauditamerica): “Discover the shocking results of the First Amendment audit at Veterans Affairs in Nevada. Explore important First Amendment audit and civil liberties issues with Accountability Alert – your go-to source for the latest First Amendment audit news, the best First Amendment audit videos, a unique AI-powered police Sean Paul Reyes, The Long Island Audit, wins his fifth consecutive legal victory. Jason Gutterman, a self-described photo journalist and First Amendment auditor, was arrested outside the UPS Customer Center at 3205 Minnesota Ave. Constitution provides that Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of Individuals video government buildings and employees, and the bloggers or auditors identify themselves as First Amendment Auditors. WHERE DO FIRST AMENDMENT AUDIT OCCUR? Public Property First Amendment Auditing confers NO right to Trespass on Private Property. Not now, not EVER! 1st Amendment Audits across the United States! If you would like to support, the links are Witness a high-stakes encounter as we delve into an intense police audit confrontation in this captivating YouTube Short! Experience the tension and scrutiny From audit to lawsuit. See what happens when rights are tested! #audit #firstamendment #lawsuit”. Auditors This is newly-released body cam footage showing police officers in New London, Connecticut confronting First Amendment auditors in their department parking lot. SaulGood; Start EVERYTHING that follows VIOLATING THE RULES OF A BUILDING is the result of the violator's own action in doing so. A routine First Amendment Audit uncovers widespread corruption in a small New Hampshire town. As a result of this new phenomenon, many agencies are evaluating how to respond to these so-called “auditors. Rights Law § 79-p; the New York City Right to Record Act , N. It is often categorized by its practitioners, known as auditors, as activism and citizen journalism that tests constitutional rights, in particular the right to photograph and video record in a public FIRST AMENDMENT IMPLICATIONS. First Amendment audits have become a significant source of income for In more recent times, groups of individuals, claiming to be “First Amendment Auditors,” have been challenging police and gaining media exposure by filming the inside of various public spaces. fi/439TpHTPatreon: https://www. These videos often capture real-time confrontations with police officers and other law enforcement personnel. 6 See Ark. They call themselves First Amendment Auditors and Citizen Journalists. 12, 2023 and had no less than THREE separate businesses (two banks and one insurance company) call the cops on us si A First Amendment auditor just had his day in federal court against the New York Police Department. Brilliant, get a federal ruling that the 1A doesn't support your antics, really well done there Sean. Alarmed county staff approached the men and asked them what they were doing while others called the police. Today, Reyes filed a federal lawsuit against the NYPD in The cameraman, Terrell Clayton, claimed he was unlawfully detained by Colorado Springs Police. ” So if the Bay County Sheriff’s improve their training, as a result, that is a step in the right direction. For a more detailed explanation and legal analysis of the issues discussed in this blog post series (including citations to cases referenced in the post), please see Local Government Law Bulletin No. com/2014/11/florida-police-detain-jeff-gray-two-hours-issue-illegal-trespass-order-gray-gadsen-county/Flori This post is Part 1 of a multi-part series. youtube. The right to take photographs and record videos of a public space is generally protected by the First Amendment. As PRESS NH NOW investigates, he is falsely arrested, attacked Sean Paul Reyes has been documenting First Amendment Audits on his popular YouTube channel, Long Island Audit. This page is no longer being updated. To date, Gutterman has NEVER been arrested in the many encounters he has had with police. The boundaries of when people can record, and when recording can be limited, are regularly pushed and tested by journalists, government officials, regular people with cameras ― and First First Amendment auditors are people who film in and around public spaces — including government buildings — in order to test (or audit) local, state or federal government adherence to freedom of the press, which protects the right to Read more at PINAC http://photographyisnotacrime. His mission is clear, to make the government m The lawsuit alleged the City’s ordinance and its actions interfered with Salvatore’s First Amendment right to campaign. These lawsuits often prevail, with judgements or settlements that can reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars, although usually judgements of this size result from tasings or some significant injury to the plaintiff on the part of law enforcement. 14, Warmus recorded an audit at the state Department of Labor office in the City of Lockport that he published on his YouTube channel. Days after her charges of trespassing and resisting arrest Lawsuit Update Lack Luster – Jamar Table of Contents I’ve been watching videos some people consider to be 1st Amendment Audits, for at least 3 to 5 years I would say. “[There are a] few things to avoid when confronted by a First Amendment auditor,” said Piña. Previous Post: The Legal Risks of Renting with a Roommate. • Auditors are often confrontational in nature. S. Now, 50 Eleven self-styled First Amendment “auditors” who were arrested or detained by Leon Valley police during three June protests at the San Antonio suburb’s city hall filed a federal lawsuit SeanPaul Reyes, aka "The Long Island Audit," a prominent YouTuber, stands with his attorney Jacob Uriel across the street from Schenectady City Hall on Oct. . On Feb. Coincidentally, no one else was seen taking video, no one else refused to stop, thus as expected, no one else was seen being We are here to help build a community of support to help enhance the lives of those affected by tyranny,from public officials that display tyrannical behavior,police brutality,and governmental Jacksonville Police Chief Joe Williams reads a prepared statement to the city council regarding his response and steps taken following the posting of a YouTube video depicting an interaction between three officers and a First Amendment auditor. It comes two years after being arrested for "creating a disturbance" while What is a First Amendment Auditor? • Auditors tend to film or photograph government buildings, equipment, access control points, and sensitive areas, as well as recording law enforcement or military personnel present. ” We can NOT stop an Auditor from filming from a “Traditional Public Forum. 141, Responding to First Amendment “Audits” in the Local Government Context. On February 24, a YouTube channel called Amagansett Press posted a 51 minute edited video of a man and his son entering the post office on a “First Amendment audit,” to see if “these folks honor and respect LONG ISLAND AUDIT: SEANPAUL REYES: MAJOR LAWSUIT (What a surprise!) Thread starter S. KFOR took the Oklahoma State Department of Education, the State Superintendent, and the Press Secretary to court over the 1st Amendment. Sean Paul Reyes, the Long Island Audit, exits the Berwyn, IL courtroom victorious after a judge threw out the case against him for filming in a public govern The First Amendment analysis from this opinion and order signals problems for his Title 42 section 1983 First Amendment claims and for his section 1983 4th Amendment claims. City of Philadelphia upholding the public's right to film the police, the U. 666, 677 (1998). Thumbnail of a First Amendment audit video on YouTube. A New York court has dismissed all charges against well-known First Amendment auditor SeanPaul Reyes, AKA Long Island Audit, for a 2023 incident at a police station in Brooklyn. 141, Responding to First Amendment “Audits” in the Local Fellow Patriots & Freedom Lovers, I received multiple tips that the Social Services Office In Coram, NY was treating the People horribly. In reality, they often test the patience and The analysis is fact-specific, and different facts have yielded different results. This study compares arguments made on the streets during First Amendment audits (FAAs)—YouTubers who purposefully record the police—to the arguments made in the courts over the right to record. As a result, it is fueling the ire Our public servants need to understand WE won't allow them to violate our rights. Documentary written, produced, and edited by Showcase Audits. Silverthorne paid a $9,500 settlement to a “First Amendment auditor” following an incident at the post office. Unfortunately, the police in Mesa have a track record that isn’t that great. They serve as a reminder that even when lawsuits don’t result in courtroom victories Lawrence County also adjusted its policy in light of the lawsuit, and the advocacy group again asked that the case be dismissed as a result. A few municipalities have settled lawsuits brought by other First Amendment Auditors. In First Amendment audits, individuals arm themselves with video cameras, proclaim themselves “auditors,” and enter public buildings, like police precincts and libraries, to record alleged Constitutional violations. Cop-watchers record police interactions. Third Circuit stated that the right "goes beyond In September 2020, Oregon journalist April Ehrlich was arrested while reporting at a public park. ” Many of these encounters do not escalate, however, A man advocating for homeless veterans was detained by Alpharetta police after holding a sign outside City Hall. 2K Likes, 1746 Comments. In that case, Judge Lange signed off on the dismissal of the First Amendment claims on Dec. First Amendment auditors seek to test their rights (as they understand them) under the First Amendment to the U. 14, but noted that Lawrence County “do(es) not agree” that Dakotans for Health is entitled to legal fees. They’re there to test whether government employees and law enforcement understand the public’s rights to record in public places. I went to investiga As a result, more first amendment auditors have come to Mesa, AZ. A “First Amendment audit” refers to the practice of exercising one’s First Amendment right to video-record in public spaces such as government buildings, public safety buildings and parking lots. The First Amendment guarantees, in addition to freedom of speech, free exercise of religion, and freedom of the press. While currently under appeal, the first court ordered the restrictions removed. Rich Kirby, Patch Staff. You see a lot of these - but not necessarily a lot of them that result in police officer discipline and policy change. Aug. With a camera in hand, he goes around public spaces On November 3, 2020, two men wearing tactical vests and armed with a handgun stood outside a ballot box and filmed voters dropping off ballots in front of the Arapahoe County administration building in Littleton, Colorado. Posted Wed, Feb 1, 2023 at 1:05 pm ET. “First Amendment audits” are a phenomenon that occurs in local government agencies across Washington and the country. As we discussed last month, “First Amendment Auditors” have been challenging police and gaining media exposure by filming the inside of various public spaces and officers performing their duties on the street. Auditors most often seek “Traditional Public Forums. This is one of those rare ones. And he won. As a result of this new phenomenon, many agencies are evaluating how to respond to these so-called “auditors. The purpose of his recording appears to be multi-faceted: to provoke confrontations with public officials, security guards and police officers, My email inbox blew up this weekend after a nationally-known First Amendment auditor on Youtube posted a video of his interaction at a courthouse that is local to me, in Greenbrier County, West Virginia. SILVERTHORNE — The town Bergeson’s attempt to charge the two men with first-degree trespass was rejected by his supervisors. or removed from the property. People have been asking for my take on this video, and I did Now he has a federal lawsuit where he will probably prevail on the local NY law and force the NYPD to take down no-video signs in the lobbies of their precincts, but the judge has already said his First Amendment claim is not going to succeed. youtube Bailey said he used to be a First Amendment auditor and believed he was helping to protect constitutional freedoms. October 2, 2020 News Now Houston A video from a YouTuber and First Amendment auditor showing him being criminally trespassed from Carthage City Hall last week by a police officer has provoked thousands of online comments and phone calls from all The police were called in by a Danbury Public Library security guard to confront "First Amendment auditor" SeanPaul Reyes, of Bellport, New York, recording video inside the library. , across the street from Mosley High School. Constitution. In response to the county staff’s An auditor can film anything he/she can see while standing in a public place. As far as I know right now, the appealate court has enacted a temporary stay while the appeal is taking place, which was ammended last week to allow Long Island Audit to record in any police station. ID Refusal, Cop Owner, Walk of shame. The NYPD Patrol Guide states that while recording the police is generally allowed, "Members of the public are The City of Wildwood settled a lawsuit for $295,000 after they were accused of depriving a city council candidate of his first amendment rights back in 2018. After examining FAAs on YouTube (N = 120), the results reveal that the arguments made on the streets reflect and differ from the arguments in case law. Y. ’” Our public servants need to understand WE won't allow them to violate our rights. The American Civil Liberties Union has filed a lawsuit claiming that Michigan voters in several Detroit suburbs were subjected to the threats, harassment, and intimidation at polling places in KULT News visited Marysville, OH on Oct. Not now, not EVER! 1st Amendment Audits across the United States! If you would like to support, the links are This study compares arguments made on the streets during First Amendment audits (FAAs)—YouTubers who purposefully record the police—to the arguments made in the courts over the right to record. In its 2017 decision in Fields v. Compared to other auditors, Long Island Audit is a saint. The Underground Auditor won his case today in court! He acted as his own attorney and won the case! He will go live tonight at 8:00 PM on his channel the Und First Amendment Audits have been around for years, but they’ve recently become more prominent, a significant social media and political phenomenon spurred on by the taped recording of George Floyd’s murder and increasing doubts about government activities related to COVID-19 restrictions. A Lebanon County judge convicted “First Amendment auditor” Charles Lanza on Wednesday of summary disorderly conduct, a charge that stemmed from a confrontation between Lanza and a sheriff’s FLORENCE, S. SeanPaul Reyes, aka 'The Long Island Audit,' is charged with trespassing after flouting warnings to stop recording at Schenectady City Hall. Civ. SUBSCRIBE and turn on notifications so you do Summit Daily: The town of Silverthorne agreed to pay a settlement of $9,500 after police asked a man filming inside the Silverthorne Post Office to leave. patreon. C. First Amendment audits are a largely American social movement that usually involves photographing or filming from a public space. First Amendment Auditors go to public places, including law enforcement While some audits end in lawsuits, in this specific 1st amendment audit by the Rowdy Podcast YouTube Channel results in the auditor having one officer give another a breathalyzer Stay tuned for future articles on first amendment audits! 2020-11-05. Stay cool, Be polite, Assert Your Rights, and Always Film The Police. Later, after a video of the exchange was posted to Kokoszka’s YouTube channel Constitution State, Mayor Michael Passero Reyes has been arrested multiple times for filming in public places, including inside New York City police stations. The First Amendment of the U. They're forcing departments to train their officers to respect First Amendment rights. Failed audits can result in liability for the municipality. Television Comm’n v. It ultimately resulted in the police officer being suspended. 15. Welcome to Showcase Audits, where we highlight First Amendment Auditors and the important work these Patriots do: exposing tyrants, holding government workers This post is Part 7 of a multi-part series co-authored by Kristi Nickodem and Kristina Wilson. To film police during the course of their civil duties. (WPDE) — Joshua Roberts, 34, said he was just exercising his rights as an First Amendment Auditor earlier this month when he was arrested by a Florence County Sheriff's deputy. But freedoms of speech and the press are not unlimited. Admin. The "First Amendment auditor" was found guilty of simple trespass, but acquitted of creating a public disturbance. Piña also advised officers that they should not be completely open and truthful with First Amendment auditors. znt ceekj yvgywa zypq jfdw bttud gdkl onnw rhdg wlrpx hiftfda hsps dhcomo uaa kga